RIP Filthy

I'm wondering what I'll do for movie reviews now that the Filthy Critic is dead. Even though some of his reviews were a little gratuitous, they always seemed to be right-on. If he disliked something, then I typically disliked it. If he liked something, more often than not, I thought it was pretty good too. And his reviews were pretty amusing. He certainly had a refreshingly original concept of telling it like it was. When something sucks, it sucks. (Take a look at the "Quote Whore of the Week" sidebar in the lower right of his site for a quick comparison between Filthy and a "normal" movie critic.) He said over and over again that Hollywood makes crappy movies because they have no incentive to do anything besides make money. I never thought about that until he brought it up. I always thought quality automatically meant success, but I guess not. He felt that everyone (Hollywood as well as critics) kept this not-so-secret arrangement alive with smarmy insincerity, or outrigth deception. So when he reviewed a movie which sucked, it got one honest finger. I can respect that.

Is Filthy really dead? Yes. And no. I did a little searching during lunch. The main thing I found was this interview with Matt Weatherford, Filthy's normal alter ego. It was apparently given on , 5 days after Filthy died wobbling down the slow lane.

I never knew Filthy's real name until I read that interview. It's nowhere on his web site. So was Matt dead? A little more searching leads to Ben Garvey's web site (which also links to the interview above; I would have rather been to Ben's site first and gotten it all out of the way in one shot). Ben emailed Filthy's cronies at bigempire.com about Matt. Turns out that Filthy is indeed dead, Matt not so much.

I'm glad that no non-virtual people got hurt, but I'm also sad that I won't get to see what Filthy thinks about the latest movies.

Comments for: RIP Filthy

Bummer! Filthy rocked. He should've had a PayPal button up on his site so he could get some dills for his effort... Oh well.

Posted by Tess at August 26, 2003 9:21 AM

The interview with Filthy was actually posted in May.

http://pitchforkmedia.com/columns/get-that-out-of-your-mouth/

03-05-22.shtml

Posted by Correction at September 8, 2003 7:28 PM

I couldn't find a date on the interview, and Google News gave a 8/13 date, so my bad.

Still sucks he's gone...

Posted by wee at September 8, 2003 7:35 PM

He's back...

Posted by Niall at May 6, 2004 10:04 AM

Holy shit!!! Amazing news!!! I was only yesterday lamenting Filthy's departure. I'm now happy once more....

Posted by wee at May 6, 2004 7:34 PM

Some of Filth's reviews have sucked lately (See Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban). There have been too many typos, and not enough filthy goodness. I wonder if he's burned out, or if there is an imposter who fills in for him sometimes.

Posted by McBane at June 7, 2004 11:31 AM

Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?